How to build a fair sales commission system: targets, tiers, returns and payout
A fair commission system rests on written rules a seller understands before selling: a clear target for a set period, tiers or levels that raise the rate as achievement grows, a stated rule for taking back commission on returns, and approval after the period ends, then a documented payout. It is calculated from the sales data in the system itself, not a side spreadsheet, so each seller sees their commission as management does. What destroys trust in commissions most is not a small rate but unclear sums and rules changed after the sale.
What makes a commission system fair?
Fairness in commissions does not mean everyone gets the same amount; it means each seller knows in advance how their commission is worked out, it is worked out the same way for everyone in their role, and they can check it themselves. A seller who cannot see why they earned SAR 800 this month and 1,200 last month will assume a mistake, even if the sum is right.
So a fair plan starts from a few fixed principles:
- Clarity: written rules, every term explained in the seller's words.
- Stability: rules do not change mid-period; any change applies to coming periods and is logged.
- Verifiability: the seller sees their sales and commission in the system itself, invoice by invoice.
- Tied to real value: commission on what stayed sold after returns, not on what went out the door and came back.
What is the target measured on?
Net sales is the commonest measure, but not the only one. Your business may be better served by a target in units, invoices, new customers, gross profit, or amounts collected from customers. A wholesale rep selling on credit, for instance, may be rewarded on collection rather than sales, so uncollectable debt does not pile up.
The rule is to measure a seller on what they can influence: a cashier does not choose who walks in, but does shape the average invoice and add-on sales, while a branch manager shapes the whole branch's sales. A target the seller has no levers for becomes luck, not an incentive.
Set the period precisely: daily for a shift cashier, weekly, monthly or quarterly. Count periods from the plan's start date rather than necessarily the 1st, so a seller is not measured on days the plan did not exist. Decide too whether credit sales count toward the target or cash sales only.
How do you design tiers and levels?
Tiers raise the rate as achievement rises, rewarding those who beat the target. For example: 1% from 80% to 100% of target, 1.5% from 100% to 120%, and 2% above 120%. There are two ways to pay them, and the difference is large enough to be written plainly in the plan:
Besides tiers on total sales, retailers use bands on the piece's price: a fixed amount or a percentage for each piece sold within a price range, to encourage higher-priced items. A fixed bonus can be added at a given achievement, with a cap on commission so exceptional cases stay within budget.
- Highest level reached: the rate of the level reached applies to all sales. Simple and motivating, but it makes a big jump at each level's edge.
- Graduated: each level's rate applies only to the part within it, like income tax brackets. Smoother, and cheaper at the edges.
Is the target counted with or without VAT?
This point causes many disputes if left open. The seller sees the invoice total with VAT; the accountant sees revenue before VAT. Set a target of SAR 100,000 without saying which, and the seller thinks it is met when invoices reach 100,000 with VAT, while their revenue before VAT is only about 86,957.
One practical answer: measure the target and levels on sales including VAT, the figure the seller sees and follows, and pay the commission rate on sales before VAT, since VAT is not the company's revenue. What matters is writing this beside the target, in the plan and on the seller's screen, not leaving it to interpretation.
How is commission taken back on returns?
If commission was paid on a sale and the goods came back, the company paid commission on revenue that never materialised. The fair rule is that a return takes back everything the original sale earned: its share of the level's rate, the price band's amount and any item rule, and that it lowers achievement toward the target too.
If the return comes after the period's commission was approved and paid, the approved period is not recalculated; what that particular invoice earned is deducted from the seller's balance, which may go negative until future commissions cover it. That is why a running balance per seller is needed: a ledger showing what was approved, paid and taken back.
How are branch targets and supervisors' commissions built?
In stores where several sellers serve shared customers, an individual target breeds competition for the customer instead of service. The alternative is a branch target: the level is reached on all the branch's sales whoever made them, and each seller is paid the rate on their own sales. The team works toward one target, and each keeps what they sold.
Supervisors and branch or project managers earn on the sales of the unit they oversee. The problem comes when the supervisor changes mid-period: whose are the first two weeks' sales? The fair answer is to keep each supervisor's term and credit each invoice to whoever held the unit at the moment it was issued.
How are commissions approved and paid?
A period's commission is not approved before it ends; approving a month halfway drops its second half's sales or forces a recalculation after payout. Once the period is over, the commissions manager reviews the results, who reached what and what each is owed, with each seller's details. Anything in doubt is rejected with a written reason and stays unapproved while the rejection stands.
Approval should have an accounting effect: approved commission is booked as a liability per employee in an owed-commissions account, then paid on the plan's schedule, with salary, weekly or daily, through a payment voucher the accountant approves. The owed-commissions balance in the books then matches what each employee sees in their own commission statement.
What are the common commission mistakes?
Most commission problems come from calculating outside the system, or from missing rules. These recur most:
- Working commissions out in a separate spreadsheet, so the seller's figure differs from management's with no way to check.
- One login shared by several cashiers, so no one knows who sold what.
- Not taking commission back on returns, rewarding sales that never stuck.
- Changing the plan mid-period, or editing it with no log of what changed and when.
- Leaving 'is the target with or without VAT?' without a written answer.
How does Arkan build a commission system?
In Arkan commissions are built as plans that read as they pay: the target and its measure (net sales, quantity, invoices, new customers, gross profit or collection), levels paid on the highest reached or graduated, price bands per piece, a bonus and a cap, with a plain-words summary of what the plan pays. Targets and levels read VAT included, the rate on sales before VAT. A target can be measured on the whole cost center, and supervisors, group and project managers are each paid for their own term.
A return takes back everything its sale earned, and each employee has a balance ledger showing what was approved, paid and taken back. No period is approved before it ends, a result can be rejected with a written reason, and sales made after approval are worked out as a separate top-up. Approval posts the commission to the owed-commissions account in the employee's name, paid by a payment voucher or with salary, or received by the cashier from the drawer at their shift's closing. Cashiers can see «my commissions» on their screen, commissions are switched on project by project, and only those given the right edit plans, with a log of every change.
Common questions
What is the difference between highest-level and graduated commission?
With highest level, the rate of the level reached applies to all sales; with graduated, each part of the sales takes only its own level's rate.
Is commission paid on the amount including VAT?
Usually the rate is paid on sales before VAT, the company's revenue, while the target is sometimes measured with VAT, the figure the seller sees. What matters is writing it in the plan.
What happens to commission on a sale returned after payout?
What that invoice earned is deducted from the seller's balance, even if it goes negative for a while, and is covered by later commissions.
How do I pay two cashiers working one drawer?
Each cashier signs in under their own name, so each invoice is credited to whoever made it, and the commission stays with its seller, not whoever closed the shift.
When should I approve a month's commission?
After the month ends and its last shifts are closed, so all its sales and returns are counted.